Five years ago, Ginny Nolan left her music career behind in Nashville to take over her family's Christmas shop, Silver Bells, in her hometown of Comfort, Kentucky. Now, as she struggles to pay the bills and faces an imminent foreclosure, coffee-chain owner Nick Day offers to buy her out and convert Silver Bells into his next cafe location. Unbeknownst to Ginny, Nick has a mysterious past that involves her and Comfort. Meanwhile, Ginny's ex-flame and songwriting partner, Tyler Benton, arrives in town, seeking her help to write his next hit song and save his career.